A $40 Million Victory

Reimagining Fundraising Through Powerful Storytelling

Emotional Storytelling

Home

Work

Emotional Storytelling

Client

Drake University

Challenge

Storytelling challenge 2

Facing donor fatigue and increasing competition for philanthropic dollars, the university needed to quickly raise funds and craft an inspiring narrative for diverse stakeholders within a tight three-year timeframe. The campaign aimed to unify alumni, students, faculty, staff, and the community — each with unique motivations — under a compelling vision to drive collective giving.






Our Reality

Developing impactful messages under an extremely tight timeline while engaging multiple stakeholder groups.


Our Goal

Foster deep, emotional connections with critical audiences to support Drake University’s largest capital campaign.

ALUMNI

CURRENT STUDENTS 

FACULTY

STAFF

THE COMMUNITY

arrow

Storytelling insights

Insight & Strategy


EMOTION ADDS POWER TO YOUR STORIES


Storytelling insights 02 600x900


Our experience, plus research from Nonprofit Source, shows the profound impact of emotional storytelling

  • Nonprofits using storytelling retain 45% of donors (vs. 27% without)
  • Storytelling-focused organizations raise twice as much money
  • Emotionally engaging pitches are more likely to receive funding


These insights guided our strategy to humanize Drake’s mission, showcasing real student experiences and the tangible impact of donor contributions. By tapping into universal themes like hope and community, we created personal connections that inspired individuals to contribute. Creating emotional stories that inspire action requires a delicate balance of authenticity, connection, and purpose.


Additional research by Campaign Monitor provided critical insights:

52% 

of donors are inspired by compelling reasons to give

36% 

are motivated by pictures and stories of impact

58.5% 

prefer hearing from individuals within an organization

SOLUTION

“The Ones” Campaign

Storytelling solution 01 2


“The Ones: Drake’s Campaign for the Bold & Brave” incorporated a comprehensive storytelling approach that brought the university’s vision to life by focusing on three key principles:

1. Authenticity

We focused on authentic stories showcasing Drake University's real impact:

  • Individual student journeys

  • Transformative moments in education

  • Real challenges overcome through Drake’s support

2. Emotional Resonance

Focusing on emotional impact, we developed stories that:

  • Highlight personal growth

  • Demonstrate community impact

  • Connect individual experiences to broader educational missions

3. Multi-Channel Storytelling

We ensured consistent, compelling narratives across platforms:

  • Hero videos featuring student testimonials

  • Social media content with shareable, impactful moments

  • Website stories that provide deeper context

  • Print materials that bring individual experiences to life


WHO WE TARGETED


The campaign approach transformed fundraising from a transactional ask to an emotional invitation to be part of something meaningful — Drake University’s mission to create bold, brave learners who can transform communities.


CORE



Previous and Likely Donors

  • Already invested in Drake’s vision and mission

  • Want to be inspired by new ideas and thinking

  • Goal: Inspire them to be ambassadors/evangelists for the campaign


GROWTH



Disengaged Alumni and Friends

  • Potential existing Drake connection, but less emotion/affinity
  • Need a reason to reconnect, whether emotional or rational
  • Goal: Inspire affinity for the university and motivate them to give back


THE PUBLIC



Greater Population and Beyond

  • Aware of Drake, may have a tangential connection 
  • Less likely to give but can be influenced by the work we do
  • Goal: Create a positive impression with them

KEY BUSINESS OUTCOMES

Leveraging our team’s expertise, we crafted narratives that showcased Drake’s educational impact and potential. 

The campaign — fueled by emotional narratives — exceeded its $225 million goal by $40 million, proving the power of authentic storytelling to inspire audiences to get involved and give.

Storytelling outcomes 2


13.8K+

INDIVIDUAL DONORS

were inspired to give.

10x

MORE ENGAGEMENT GENERATED

on social media compared to typical annual results.

26%

INCREASE IN EMAIL CLICK-THROUGH RATES

across various constituent audiences, achieving higher traction for the fundraising campaign.

Hexes med burgundy
The ones banners 2

The campaign ultimately exceeded its $225 million goal by $40 million.

JCP Drake 00897 2000x600
Next Case Study
First-Party Data Collection

Transforming First-Party Data Collection

In an era of increasing digital complexity and privacy regulations, capturing high-quality first-party data has become a critical yet challenging mandate for B2B marketers. See how 2RM helped Miller Electric transform their approach, opening new paths for customer engagement and business growth.

GO TO CASE STUDY

Two Rivers Marketing will help you build brand relevance, transform your customer relationships, and drive real change for your business. Let's talk.

Work with us